Annie May's Sweet Café

At Annie May's Sweet Cafe we understand the difficulties of living with food allergies. But, we believe all people are created equal and therefore deserve all the delicious treats life has to offer! All of our bakery items are Allergen-Free: free of Wheat, Gluten, Milk, Eggs, Peanut, Tree nuts (excluding coconut), Shellfish, Sesame, and Soy!

Tuesday - Friday: 9am to 6pm
Saturday: 9am to 3pm
Sunday: 11am to 3pm
Monday: Closed

Thanksgiving and Christmas Holiday Menu

holiday sugar cookies.jpg

Annie May’s Sweet Café Holiday Menu 2018

All menu items are now free of the Top 8 food allergens

You may order off this menu as well as our regular bakery menu

All orders are pre-paid and must be place by November 15th for a November 20th/21st pick up, or placed by December 16th for a December22nd/23rd/24th pick up.

We will be open 9am – 12pm on Monday, December 24th for pick ups and last minute needs.

 Stuffing/Dressing  (serving size is about one cup)

Take and bake - small     Serves 2-3          $10.00

Take and bake – large     Serves 10-12      $25.00

  Mac and “Cheese”  - top 8 free only

Take and bake mac and cheese (serves 2-3)          $10


***Due to space limitations/large volumes of bread orders, all bread is given frozen.**

Focaccia – with red onion and herbs     4pk/$7.00                Sandwich Buns              4pk/ $7.00

Everything Buns                                                         4pk/ $7.00               Dinner rolls                    ½ dz/$5.00   1 dz/ $9.00

Bagels (plain, onion, everything, cinnamon sugar)        4/ $11.00

  Allergen Free Biscuits and Gravy (vegan)

Biscuits                               4pk/ $7.00                         2-pack (two biscuits/8oz gravy)                                $7

4 pack (four biscuits/pint of gravy)           $13        Family pack (8 biscuits/quart of gravy)                    $22

 Breakfast Items/ Sweet Breads

Allergen Free/ Vegan Coffee Cakes                                        $25.00 each

Choose blueberry, cinnamon, pumpkin, carrot, orange cranberry

Cinnamon rolls – Take and bake only                                                    4pk/$13.50

 Seasonal Items

Ginger Spice Cookies                                                                                                $28/dozen

Pumpkin Spice Cookies (please specify no glaze or maple glazed)                $28/dozen

Gingerbread Men                                                                                                      $40/dozen

Decorated sugar cookies (assorted only)                                                             $40/ dozen

Pumpkin Pie Toaster treats                                                                                      $55.00/dz



All 9” tarts are free of the Top 8 and garnished with coconut whip

Pumpkin, French Silk (Chocolate), Key Lime, Lemon                         $25/each (serves 6-8)

Fruit Pie (serves 6-8)   choose: blueberry, apple, cherry, peach                                                 $25 - streusel top

                                                                                                            $30 – double crust

Chocolate coconut pie (serves 6-8)                                                    $32.00

Pie shell – unbaked                                                                            $10.00

Savory pie shell - unbaked                                                                 $10.00

Chocolate pie shell – (baked)                                                             $10.00

Other items

White chocolate peppermint bark (4oz serving)                               $6.50

Chocolate toffee box (4 oz serving)                                                   $6.50

Assorted chocolates (8-10 pieces)                                                     $16.00/box


Gingerbread house kit- includes house pieces, frosting, candy (available for shipping)

                         Not Available for pick up until Dec 1st           $38.00


Site designed by Scott May